What to Do When Your Insurance Company Denies Your Claim

Picture this: You’ve just discovered a pipe burst in your ceiling or a tree came crashing down during a storm. You take a deep breath, file your home insurance claim, and wait for the magic words: “Approved.” But instead, you get the dreaded response—your insurance company denied the claim.

Talk about a gut punch.



Before you start imagining life with a bucket under every leak, take a step back. Denied home insurance claims are frustrating but not the end of the road. In fact, many claims are denied for reasons that can be appealed or corrected. This blog post will walk you through why claims get denied, what you can do about it, and when to bring in the big guns.

Why Do Insurance Companies Deny Claims in the First Place?

There’s nothing quite like opening a letter that says, “We regret to inform you…” to make your blood pressure spike. But before you go full Hulk on your mailbox, it helps to understand why your insurance company denied your claim.

Here are some common reasons:

• Incomplete or incorrect documentation: Missing receipts, blurry photos, or vague descriptions can get your claim tossed out faster than expired milk.
• The damage isn’t covered: Not all policies are created equal. If your policy doesn’t cover flooding, for instance, even Noah’s Ark wouldn’t save your claim.
• Missed deadlines: Insurance companies love deadlines. Miss one, and your claim might be denied just on that basis alone.
• Pre-existing or maintenance-related damage: If your roof has been leaking since the last election and you just got around to filing, the insurer might blame neglect rather than an insurable event.
• Suspicion of fraud: If anything smells fishy to the adjuster, they might deny the claim outright until further investigation.
  
  

It’s not personal, it’s business… cold, corporate business. But you don’t have to accept the denial at face value.

Step One: Don’t Panic, Review the Denial Letter

We get it—seeing the words “claim denied” can make anyone want to scream into a pillow. But your first move should be simple: read the denial letter carefully.



This letter usually outlines:

• The specific reason for the denial
• The section(s) of your policy they believe support that decision
• Your right to appeal and how to start that process
  
  

Use this as your roadmap. Highlight confusing terms. Make notes. Google words like “exclusion” and “wear and tear” if needed (or just ask us—we speak fluent Insurance).

Pro tip: If your insurer didn’t give you a clear explanation, request a written breakdown. You’re legally entitled to it.

Step Two: Gather Your Documentation Like a Boss

The next step is all about paperwork power. You’ll want to collect every piece of evidence that supports your claim and counters the denial.

Here’s what to dig up:

• Photos and videos of the damage (before and after if you have them)
• Receipts and repair estimates
• Inspection reports from contractors or professionals
• Copies of correspondence with the insurance company
• Your full insurance policy (not just the summary)
  
  

You’re basically building a mini legal case, so the more thorough, the better.

Step Three: File a Denied Claim Appeal Like a Pro

Here’s where you roll up your sleeves. If you believe the denial was incorrect, you can and should file a denied claim appeal.

What should your appeal include?

• A letter stating your intent to appeal
• A point-by-point rebuttal of the reasons for denial
• All relevant evidence and documentation
• A copy of the original denial letter
  
  

Make sure your tone is polite but firm. Think “persistent PTA mom,” not “angry TikTok rant.”

Tips for a solid appeal:

• Be organized—use headings, bullet points, and label your evidence
• Stick to facts, not feelings
• Refer to your policy wording to back your arguments
• Keep copies of everything you send
  
  

Once submitted, follow up within 10 to 15 business days. Don’t be shy—they’re not your dentist, you’re allowed to chase them down.

When to Bring in the Professionals: Public Adjusters to the Rescue

Sometimes, despite your best efforts, the process is just too overwhelming. Or maybe your appeal hit a brick wall. That’s when a public adjuster like us steps in.

What we do:

• Review your entire policy and claim
• Identify loopholes and missed coverage
• Negotiate directly with the insurance company on your behalf
• Help reopen denied home insurance claims or bump up underpaid claims
  
  

Unlike the insurance company’s adjuster (who works for them), we work for you. You’re the boss in this relationship.

And let’s be honest—just like you wouldn’t pull your own tooth, you probably shouldn’t go toe-to-toe with an insurance company without backup.

Common Mistakes to Avoid After a Claim Denial

Call in the Experts: Nuclaim, Inc. Public Adjusters in Houston, TX Are Here to Help

You Don’t Have to Face the Insurance Giants Alone

FAQ